Pay your rep what you agreed when the customer pays.
Paying a 1099 sales rep is simpler than paying an employee. There's no payroll and nothing to withhold. You need a clear agreement, one tax form before you start and one after the year ends.
Here's the whole setup in four steps.
Keep it to one page. It should answer five questions:
Almost every commission argument starts with one of these left vague.
No. You pay the full amount. The rep pays their own income tax and self-employment tax.
The one exception: if a rep never gives you a W-9 with their tax ID, the IRS requires you to hold back 24%. That's called backup withholding. Get the W-9 first and it never comes up.
When the customer pays. It's fairer to you, and reps can see exactly where their money comes from.
Here's an example. A rep earns 10% on a $10,000 sale, and the customer pays $2,500 a month.
| Pay at close | Pay when the customer pays | |
|---|---|---|
| Each month | $1,000 up front, then nothing | $250 every time $2,500 comes in |
| Customer stops after 2 months | You ask the rep for $500 back | Nothing to ask for |
Splits: set them by role and apply them to every payment. If the closer gets 8% and the setter 2%, a $2,500 payment means $200 to the closer and $50 to the setter.
Refunds: take commission back in proportion. If a customer gets $1,000 of a $5,000 payment back, a rep on 10% gives back $100. If the rep has already been paid, take it off their next commission instead of sending them a bill.
The idea is the same everywhere: contractors handle their own tax and employees go through payroll. Here are the general rules in each region.
| Contractor | Employee | |
|---|---|---|
| United States | No withholding. W-9 first, 1099-NEC at $2,000+ | Through payroll, with tax withheld. Reported on a W-2 |
| United Kingdom | No tax taken out. The rep pays Income Tax and National Insurance through Self Assessment | Through PAYE payroll, with Income Tax and National Insurance taken out |
| Canada | No source deductions. Issue a T4A (box 048) if you pay more than $500 in a year | Through payroll, with income tax, CPP and EI taken out. Reported on a T4 |
| European Union | The rep invoices you and pays their own tax. Cross-border invoices between businesses usually use the VAT reverse charge | Through local payroll in the rep's country, with tax and social contributions |
In the EU and UK, self-employed sales agents also have legal rights over their commission. That includes when it's due and a statement of what they're owed. Rules differ by country, so check locally before you hire.
It depends on how you work together, not what the contract says. If you set their hours, train them like staff and they only sell for you, they may count as an employee. Each country has its own test: the IRS's three-part test in the US, HMRC's status checker in the UK and the CRA's guidance in Canada. If you're unsure, check before the first payment.
Sources: IRS: 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC instructions · IRS: Backup withholding · IRS: Contractor or employee? · HMRC: Check employment status for tax · CRA: Reporting fees for services · EU Directive 86/653/EEC on commercial agents. This is general information, not tax advice. Check your situation with an accountant.